What to say when a friend says “You’re not thinking outside the box!”

When a friend says You’re not thinking outside the box!, it can be frustrating and make you defensive. However, instead of taking it personally, you can use this opportunity to have a productive conversation and explore new ideas together. Here are some strategies and phrases to help you respond effectively:

Acknowledge their perspective

When someone says you’re not thinking outside the box, they might be trying to encourage you to be more creative or innovative. Acknowledge their perspective and show them that you value their input.

Hey, I appreciate your honesty! Can you help me understand what you mean by thinking outside the box in this situation?

I see what you mean. I was stuck in my old ways of thinking, thanks for pointing that out!

Seek clarification

Ask questions to understand what they mean by thinking outside the box. This will help you better understand their expectations and what they’re looking for.

What do you mean by thinking outside the box in this context? Can you give me an example?

How do you think I could approach this problem in a more innovative way?

Offer an alternative solution

If you have a different approach or solution, share it with your friend and explain your thought process. This shows that you’re willing to think critically and find alternative solutions.

I was thinking of approaching it this way, but I’m open to other ideas. What do you think about…


I understand where you’re coming from, but I think we could also consider…


Share your thought process

Explain how you arrived at your current solution or idea. This helps your friend understand your thinking and might even spark new ideas.

I came up with this solution because I thought about X, Y, and Z. Do you think that’s a good approach?

I was considering a few factors, including A, B, and C. Do you think I’m missing something?

Explore new ideas together

Work together to brainstorm new ideas and explore different solutions. This collaborative approach can lead to innovative solutions and strengthen your friendship.

Let’s brainstorm some new ideas together! What do you think about…


I’m stuck in my thinking, can you help me come up with some outside-the-box solutions?

Deflect criticism with humor

If the comment comes across as criticism, use humor to deflect it and turn the conversation into a more positive direction.

Haha, yeah I guess I was stuck in my comfort zone! Thanks for kicking me out of it!

I guess I was feeling a bit too comfy in my box, thanks for giving me a nudge!

Avoid becoming defensive

Remember, the goal is to have a productive conversation, not to get defensive or take it personally. Stay calm, listen actively, and respond thoughtfully.

I appreciate your feedback, can you help me understand what you mean?

I’m open to new ideas, can we explore this further together?

In conclusion, when a friend says You’re not thinking outside the box!, use it as an opportunity to explore new ideas, seek clarification, and collaborate on finding innovative solutions. By responding thoughtfully and avoiding defensiveness, you can turn a potential criticism into a productive and enriching conversation that strengthens your friendship.

Be kind ❤

Related Posts